
Feb 12, 2010
Quentin Tarantino's war: t'was ever thus

Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Politics, Pop, Books, Movies
“A master-class‑–immersive, detailed, meticulous, privileged inside-dope… Tom Shone is the king of critical cool.” — Craig Raine
“An up-close and personal look at one of Hollywood’s most successful directors…This erudite book is packed with extensive, expansive discussions about Nolan’s films… insights into what he was trying to accomplish with each film; and the movies, directors, books, art, architecture, and music that influenced him…. Fans of Nolan’s films will find this revealing book invaluable.” — Kirkus, starred review
"A sweet and savvy page-turner of a valentine to New York, the strange world of fiction, the pleasures of a tall, full glass and just about everything else that matters" — Gary Shteyngart, author of Super Sad True Love Story and Absurdistan
"A cocktail with bite. I downed it in one" — Helen Fielding, author of Bridget Jones's Diary
"A deft, witty satire which casts its sharp eye over the absurdities of addiction, recovery and contemporary New York" — Marcel Theroux, author of Far North
“Laugh-out-loud funny” — Toby Young, author of How to Lose Friends and Alienate People
"Tom Shone's superb debut is a wise and witty examination of literary celebrity, Anglo-American mystification and the cult of recovery. Shone's prose sparkles: his humor detonates smart-bombs of truth" — Stephen Amidon, author of Human Capital
“A cutting comic debut” — The Sunday Times
“Clever, witty, acerbic, warm” — Geoff Nicholson, author of Footsucker
"A sharp, funny, and ultimately touching debut novel" — Library Journal Reviews
"One of the few novels set in Manhattan that gives you a true feel for the city” — James Wolcott, Vanity Fair
"A splash of cynicism, a dash of self-doubt, and a good measure of humour.... In the Rooms is an entertaining page-turner about humanity, with plenty of hilarity" — The Economist
Dear Mr. Shone,
ReplyDeleteI'm a huge fan of your "Blockbuster", but I've got to side with my hometown (SF) critic Mick Lasalle on this one. He writes:
"It would be an epic misperception to see "Inglourious Basterds" as some irreverent pastiche. It's not. Every liberty Tarantino takes, in both tone and history, is part of the filmmaker's overarching determination to remind audiences - remind them so they feel it - that World War II was, to put it mildly, the worst thing that has ever happened. Nearly seven decades of cinematic cliche may have dulled our response. Tarantino explodes those cliches to shake us awake."
If the movie took the Basterds seriously, and weren't so outrageously and transparently fantastical, their terroristic ways would indeed be disturbing. But this isn't juvenile pulp in the vein "24"; it's better than that. Any wrong reactions to the movie ("torture is good", etc.), I think, are the fault of the audience alone - the very misspelt title of the piece tells you not to take it at face value.
You may be right. I just didn't enjoy the movie much. I tend to get a little peevish when I'm bored.
ReplyDeleteBut I'm not peevish when people say they've read and enjoyed my book! (where are my manners?) Thank you very much indeed
ReplyDeleteMy pleasure! I hope you make it out to San Francisco sometime in the not-too-distant future. :)
ReplyDeleteI hope so too — I've never been
ReplyDeleteWhat an interesting point!
ReplyDeleteIt's odd how much debate Tarantino's movies seem to provoke when, at the same time, they seem to say so little.